Showing posts with label Husserl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Husserl. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

A system of philosophy

Can we give an outline of our system of philosophy or philosophical system? Terminology is a dangerous and difficult thing.  What does the term "phenomenology" even mean? And what about "philosophical introspective psychology" or "proto-psychology" or "meta-psychology"? 

Why should we include a criticism of Husserl's phenomenology and use Husserl as a stepping stone for own philosophy?  This has to be justified.

One important feature of our philosophy is that it aims to establish itself as having strong and ancient historical (even prehistorical) roots and to offer revaluations and interpretations and many key historical philosophical figures - both Western (such as Sextus Empiricus, Plotinus and Hume) and Eastern (such as the Pali Nikayas). 

And these historical philosophical figures involve the fundamental aspect of spiritual realization or cultivation - but this does not diminish the force and rigor of the philosophy qua philosophy. Rather it defines our philosophy as a soteriological philosophy.  Furthermore, our philosophy is concerned with criteria do distinguish valid and positive spiritual doctrines and practices from those that are not so.

Our soteriological philosophy is based on introspection and the cultivation of consciousness itself - and is also concerned with establishing this as valid basis of philosophy. 

Plato's allegory of the cave provided a powerful symbolism for sharply demarcating our philosophy from contemporary phenomenology or introspective psychology.  

We are not interested in gazing at the shadows even considered as shadows, but in gazing at them qua shadows only in so far as it serves for us to go beyond the shadows. Philosophy is a map of a prison serving the sole purpose of escape - and the focus is on the energies (the "chains") that bind us to the prison and on the techniques to be developed to break out.

Our "philosophical introspective psychology" aims at identifying the fundamental structural and dynamic domains of ordinary consciousness from a soteric and transcendental perspective. As such an introspective psychology is in reality a "depth psychology", proto-psychology or meta-psychology, in that it gets behind (it unveils and brings to the light of consciousness) the energy sources by and due to which such domains come to be and persist.

But philosophical knowledge and insight, liberation, are not attained merely by watching the shadows, even pretending to be neutral and detached and watching the shadows remembering they are shadows. For then the prisoners remains chained and has concocted perhaps the most dangerous myth of all: that he can attain the truth by looking at the shadows in a certain way when still chained. No, what is required is a radical, total transformation (reversion or inversion) of the core of consciousness with regards to the totality of its experience and its relation to experience. It is only with such a breaking of the chains that the process of philosophical  knowledge and liberation can begin the ascent towards the light of truth.

The prisoner still sees the shadows and should analyze them carefully, but now the perspective is entirely different, there is alêtheia, the shadows acquire a margin, a depth, of light, they are seen from afar, from the standpoint of freedom - it is only then that they can be perceived qua shadows in the light of flux and temporality. An "analysis" and "deconstruction" can manifest now which was impossible (or distorted and illusory) before: before both the shadows and consciousness were in the same plane where the only possibility was a flat illusory phenomenology. For this last shadow-gazing is like the shadows themselves,  vague, fluctuating and stochastic-selective in nature,  blending and tangling together narratives and experiences from the past with anticipations of the future. 

The phenomenon of attachment and desire has been analyzed in its immanence, according to its dynamic structure based on mental sense-material. 

The first-person experience of the body is demonstrably intimately connected with ordinary consciousness: there are feedback processes between the two.

But after the conversion and the sundering of the chains (universal abrogation of the directed intentions of the forces and energies of behind ordinary consciousness),  we can indeed claim to lay bare the contents of consciousness as such, more specifically, the universal flux of consciousness self-reflected as pure consciousness, pure givenness, at once totally present and totally manifesting the universal condition of temporality and transience (immanent impermanence which dissolves objectivity) and the temporal intentions of memory and anticipation - and also the deconstructive analysis of the illusion and sense of ego, subject or "self". The goal is moksha which can be described as absolute consciousness, a timeless, ubiquitous state of infinite joy.

Some of the chief goals of our philosophy are: how do we develop from there  a theory of ethics based on compassion, a moral sense realism in the style of Shapshay's interpretation of Schopenhauer, more particularly, Schopenhauer's purely analytical and phenomenological work On the Basis of Morals?  More specifically, how do we develop a coherent account of "intelligence" wherein we can conclude categorically that intelligence and morality are one?

And how do we develop in this framework a systematic philosophy of logic, language and mathematics? 

There are two (possibly complementary) approaches. 

One approach is to take not classical mathematics, but a special kind of legitimate consciousness-rooted mathematics (Ur-mathematics) as the common foundation (or more loosely, presupposition) for both logic and language. Quite surprisingly Schopenhauer also has considerable importance for the history of the philosophy of logic and mathematics. Mathematics is the purest form of an a priori science of the shadows. Ur-mathematics flows directly from the fundamental structure and dynamics of imprisoned consciousness and is the foundation of both logic and cognitive-linguistic activity. It must be sharply distinguished from "classical" mathematics which historically, in its subsequent developments (such as in topos theory, modal logic or forcing), appropriated and perverted much of the original results and insights of Brouwer. We propose also a complementary theory of intuitionistic mathematics based on the fundamental intuitions of core aspects of physics and engineering.  Logic and language are thus exterior and derived from Ur-mathematics. But they also have a fundamental aspect in which they are contingent. sociologically and psychologically conditioned and conditioning. For Brouwer, a member of the Significs group, language was essentially a tool for social domination and manipulation. We can point out the incoherent, semi-consciously conditioned, temporally directed, selective, and blended aspects of the linguistic-cognitive activity of ordinary consciousness - and contrast this to the relative clarity, purity and a prior nature of Ur-mathematics. 

The other approach might be called finitist phenomenological functionalism. Every thought or meaningful expression must have its possible meaning in terms of (i.e. it must be able to be "compiled" to)  a finite, finitely specified  process involving fundamental elements of consciousness. Thus the meaning and cognitive value of all possible logic and mathematics must be reducible to feasible functional programs operating on fundamental elements of consciousness. In this approach natural language is to be formalized and dependent type theory would seem evidently to play a central role. Also the meta-reflection principle must play an important role, which shall be explained later. And there is of course a radical contrast with contemporary "naturalist" and "neuroreductionist" functionalism. 

And are traditional arguments against psychologism in need of reassessment? Was the attack against "psychologism" just a front to attack the most profound truths that are sometimes encompassed by the equally vague term "subjective idealism"? Was the psychologism attacked, for instance, by Frege and Husserl, a strawman? We note that van Atten thinks that "private language arguments" carry some weight against psychologism. For a systematic challenge to Ryle's and Wittgenstein's views opposing the primacy or at least fundamental role of individual experience, in particular with regards to language acquisition and use, see for example C.W.K Mundle's  A critique of linguistic philosophy with second thoughts : an epilogue after ten years (1979),  published by Glover & Blair. The purest form of linguistic meaning is when a tag, a symbol  becomes  a trigger, a reminder, an invocation, a mantra of a completely transcendent spiritual state.  

 Almost all of twentieth century philosophy (both anglo-american and continental) represents a profound error and a concerted effort - a socio-cultural and political agenda - to eradicate and discredit the purest forms of soteriologically oriented subjective idealism and introspective proto (or meta)-psychology, and this took place on various parallel fronts from earlier "objectivist" anti-psychologist crusade in philosophy to universal and systematic behaviouristic and materialistic downplaying of consciousness and introspection in philosophy and psychology (and this is shared by structuralism and post-modernism). This tendency - the tyranny of exploitative language divorced from consciousness -  reaches its consummation with the advent of generative AI. Following Ernst Gellner's Words and Things we can produce simultaneously and independently both an intrinsic critique and refutation of these anti-consciousness philosophies and a socio-historical analysis.   

Sunday, June 7, 2026

Meditation, phenomenology and obfuscation

There is an important missing link in the history of philosophy which has significant consequences for the history of phenomenology. This is the work of the young Rudolf Steiner. It is not fair to judge this work by his later abhorrent and manifestly false views as an occultist and cult leader any more than it would be fair to judge Heidegger's Sein und Zeit by his later similar political and cultural-anthropological views. The most important work of the young Steiner (who attended lectures by Brentano) is a work which usually goes under the title of Philosophy of Freedom (1894) but was published and revised numerous times under different titles.  Along with this work there is also much value in Steiner's earlier work on Goethe's scientific method and worldview. 

There can be no doubt that The Philosophy of Freedom, like Sein und Zeit, is a very important work and one of the masterpieces of phenomenological philosophy. In this work (and in portions of his later books such as the one on "Initiation") we find something similar to an exposition of the approach and methodology involving the transcendent self-transparency and self-illumination of thought and consciousness which we have repeatedly attempted to expound, the correct combination of "epokhê" and "satipatthâna".  

Equally important is Steiner's Goethean method of variation and "imagination". This seems to us to be the original and correct form of what later was called the method of "eidetic variation" (and the affinity for Ruskin's approach in Modern Painters seems to have gone unnoticed).  But the consequences are enormous. The combination between the philosophical-spiritual insight offered by Steiner's exposition of the Goethean method on one hand and on the other the development of modern geometric and topological theory of differential equations and dynamical systems would have been a "marriage made in heaven", two complementary aspects of the same essence,  whose union would have furnished the key to a powerful new science.

But the harmful influence of 20th-century materialist cults and their pseudoscientific dogmas (Freudian psychoanalysis, evolutionary psychology) hindered the emergence of such a science. This is the tragedy of René Thom whose work flawed by Freudian and materialist-evolutionary dogma did indeed point to such a qualitative topological science with a method based on developing higher dimensional dynamic and geometric intuition. The fact that Thom never mentioned Theodor Schwenk's Sensitive Chaos: The creation of flowing forms in water and air (preface by Jacques Cousteau) which predates Structural Stability and Morphogenesis can only be seen as an example of intellectual dishonesty. As far as I know, Thom never referred to the wonderful book by A.T. Winfree, The Geometry of Biological Time (1980) which shows how advanced topological concepts in applied science can be presented in an accessible, rigorous and clear way (cf. the explanation of phase singularities on p.26).

A major fault of René Thom was also ironically to be found on the mathematical plane. Thom, like V.I. Arnold, engaged in obfuscation and sloppy presentation of mathematical ideas.

An expert in a field has all the right to develop a conceptual shorthand for their own use or that of fellow experts. In particular, a shorthand for writing down ideas to be developed and unfolded in lectures. Such texts can also employ beautiful drawings and diagrams which may impress even the non-expert. However all this has nothing to do with writing a book whose aims is to open the gates of a knowledge to those who, while not having such a knowledge, seek earnestly for it. A book that is a genuine introduction (i.e. initiation) in the full sense of the word, and which does not only "bring in" the neophyte but presents the beauty, clarity and order of the temple in all its details and adornments.  This is the kind of book, the kind of spirit, style and approach, which every student deserves, and certainly the kind of spirit. style and approach which should be employed when presenting important philosophical, scientific and mathematical ideas to the world. To present the young student with any other kind of book can only be considered a pernicious and immoral act of deliberate obfuscation and perversion. On another occasion we hope to develop the topic of cryptography, deliberate obfuscation and "secrets of the trade". Let it just be said that this has traditionally been a not infrequent vice of academia, the deliberately ponderous, opaque, pedantic jargon which not only hinders understanding of comparatively simple concepts and arguments but also masks the author's debt (or even plagiarism) to their contemporaries or predecessors. The aim is also to appear outwardly as outstandingly intelligent, original and sophisticated and to close the doors of science to anyone outside a select few.

Besides in phenomenological philosophy and Goethean science, a tragedy occurred regarding "meditation".  There is no such thing as "meditation" in the popular sense, there is no secret powerful technique of self-help where one sits down, closes their eyes, breathes in and out, focuses their mind or attempts to detach themselves from troubling thoughts, and thus finds a cure for mental anguish or a way to gain paranormal faculties or blissful states. This goes in particular for everything connected to the term "mindfulness".  And there is evidently no easy quick philosophical-phenomenological method for the self-observation and self-transparency of consciousness.

This is not what "bhavana" or "katharsis" as in neoplatonism and the ancient mysteries was about. Rather bhavana can be likened to the building of a beautiful high-towered palace or temple, including the preparation and purification of all the materials needed as well as the ground and foundations. The "mindfulness" at work here cannot be separated from action. The popular concept of "meditation" actually only corresponds to the final royal stage in which one enters the newly built palace and climbs up many flights of stairs to survey the beauty of all the sparkling rooms and luminous windows until reaching the most wonderful of all views at the top. Before that it is the long toil and active work of the artisan and soldier - which can be be interwoven with periods of peaceful surveillance and contemplation of yet unfinished work. We do not meditate as some kind of easy, all-sufficient, way to overcome our desires, rather we first diligently and actively uproot desire-images-complexes in order to attain the peace and illumination of "meditation".  Using a software engineering metaphor, we must start with cultivation at the abstract object-oriented level before proceeding to reverse engineering at the assembly level. Thus taught both the Pali suttas and Plotinus.

A system of philosophy

Can we give an outline of our system of philosophy or philosophical system? Terminology is a dangerous and difficult thing.  What does the t...