In the past we have attempted to expound the methodology of what might be called a philosophical introspective proto-psychology (or meta-psychology), while being careful to sharply delineate such a methodology from the better known and only superficially similar approaches of Husserl's phenomenology or other later forms of phenomenology. We were also very careful to show that it had very ancient and venerable historical roots. At the time we were concerned with finding a deep meaning or non-standard philosophical interpretation of Sextus Empiricus and Hume's Treatise. Subsequently we will outline a universal historical methodology to detect its presence (we call this the "golden trunk") in the most diverse regions since prehistoric times as well as antagonistic doctrines (which are "dried leaves" separated from the life-giving energy of the golden trunk).
In addition, the essentially soteriological nature of this instrospective methodology is to be strongly demarcated from modern phenomenology and we used Plato's allegory of the Cave to illustrate a fundamental difference: we are not interested in gazing at the shadows even considered as shadows, but in gazing them qua shadows only in so far as it serves for us to go beyond the shadows. Our theory is a map of a prison serving the sole purpose of escape - and the focus is on the energies (the "chains") that bind us to the prison and on the techniques to be developed to break out. Another aspect is the presence of active forms of the cultivation of consciousness itself and the development of certain spiritual habits.
We need the utmost care in invoking such terms as "philosophical introspective insight", "analysis" and "deconstruction". For these terms, if not treated carefully, may end up encompassing the exact opposite of the methodology and systematic philosophy we are proposing.
The "philosophical instrospective psychology" aims at identifying the fundamental structural and dynamic domains of ordinary consciousness from a soteric and transcendental perspective. As such an introspective psychology is in reality a "depth psychology", proto-psychology or meta-psychology, in that it gets behind (it unveils and brings to the light of consciousness) the energy sources by and due to which such domains come to be and persist. And this is only the preliminary step. We reject thus the myth of immanence and analysis, the idea that ordinary consciousness can become a transparent spectator of its own flat immanent mental contents. This illusory doctrine aims to lay bare (through deconstructive and ultimately distorting analysis) the contents of consciousness as such, more specifically, the universal flux of consciousness self-reflected as pure consciousness, pure givenness, at once totally present and totally manifesting the universal condition of temporality and transience (immanent impermanece which dissolves objectivity) and the temporal intentions of memory and anticipation - and also the deconstructive analysis of the illusion and sense of ego, subject or "self". But this is the idea that Plato's prisoners can attain a vision of truth by watching the shadows on the wall in a detached neutral way aware that they are shadows. Nothing could be further from the truth.
In reality consciousness can only acquire depth and self- transparency by a correct division of consciousness into fundamental interrelated dynamic structures, and the unveiling of the energies and mechanisms which generate and maintain such structures, followed by acts and habits of "reversion" or "inversion". The chains must be broken and the prisoners must turn away from the shadows and the mechanisms producing them.
The attempt at shadow gazing - even shadow qua shadow gazing (i.e. the detached watching the stream of thoughts qua thoughts), can never illuminate or transcend "self" or the general "identity" belief associated with objects. It is not a state of other-worldliness or non-worldliness, disidentification and freedom, but another delusion of the prisoners in the cave. For this shadow-gazing is like the shadows themselves, vague, fluctuating and stochastic-selective in nature, blending and tangling together narratives and experiences from the past with anticipations of the future.
True self-transparency is self-transcendence and universal abrogation of the directions (intentions) of the forces and energies of behind ordinary consciousness. The goal is moksha which can be described as absolute consciousness, a timeless, ubiquitous state of infinite joy wherein is experienced the infinite oneness of universal life.
Some of the chief goals of our philosophy are: how do we develop from there a theory of ethics based on compassion, a moral sense realism in the style of Shapshay's interpretation of Schopenhauer, more particularly, Schopenhauer's purely analytical and phenomenological work On the Basis of Morals? More specifically, how do we develop a coherent account of "intelligence" wherein we can conclude categorically that intelligence and morality are one?
And how do we develop in this framework a systematic philosophy of logic, language and mathematics? Our theory is to take not classical mathematics, but a special kind of legitimate consciousness-rooted mathematics (Ur-mathematics) as the common foundation (or more loosely, presupposition) for both logic and language. Quite surprisingly Schopenhauer also has considerable importance for the history of the philosophy of logic and mathematics. Mathematics is the purest form of an apriori science of the shadows. Ur-mathematics flows directly from the fundamental structure and dynamics of imprisoned consciousness and is the foundation of both logic and cognitive-linguistic activity. It must be sharply distinguished from "classical" mathematics which historically, in its subsequent developments (such as in topos theory, modal logic or forcing), appropriated and perverted much of the original results and insights of Brouwer. We propose also a complementary theory of intuitionistic mathematics based on the fundamental intuitions of core aspects of physics and engineering. Logic and language, which are exterior and derived from Ur-mathematics, are contingent and heavily sociologically and psychologically conditioned and conditioning (there are also connections that could be made with Gadamer and decolonialist thought). We must emphasize the incoherent, semi-consciously conditioned, temporally directed, selective, and blended aspects of the linguistic-cognitive activity of ordinary consciousness - and contrast this to the relative clarity, purity and a prior nature of Ur-mathematics.
And are traditional arguments against psychologism in need of reassessment? Was the attack against "psychologism" just a front to attack the most profound truths that are sometimes encompassed by the equally vague term "subjective idealism"? Was the psychologism attacked, for instance, by Frege and Husserl, a strawman? For instance van Atten thinks that "private language arguments" carry some weight against psychologism. For a systematic challenge to Ryle's and Wittgenstein's views opposing the primacy or at least fundamental role of individual experience, in particular with regards to language acquisition and use, see for example C.W.K Mundle's A critique of linguistic philosophy with second thoughts : an epilogue after ten years (1979), published by Glover & Blair. The purest form of linguistic meaning is when a tag, a symbol becomes a trigger, a reminder, an invocation, a mantra of a completely transcendent spiritual state.
Almost all of twentieth century philosophy (both anglo-american and continental) represents a profound error and a concerted effort - a socio-cultural and political agenda - to eradicate and discredit the purest forms of soteriologically oriented subjective idealism and introspective proto (or meta)-psychology, and this took place on various parallel fronts from earlier "objectivist" anti-psychologist crusade in philosophy to universal and systematic behaviouristic and materialistic downplaying of consciousness and introspection in philosophy and psychology (and this is shared by structuralism and post-modernism). This tendency - the tyranny of exploitative language divorced from consciousness - reaches its consummation with the advent of generative AI. Following Ernst Gellner's Words and Things we can produce simultaneously and independently both an intrinsic critique and refutation of these anti-consciousness philosophies and a socio-historical analysis.