Philosophical Monologues: November 2023

Logic, therefore, is not a tool; it is an open-ended, evolving science having an ontology of its own. Mathematics is but one of its parts, and its full scope is yet to be discovered. Given the definition of validity, every necessary thought whose analysis contains only purely logical objects is valid. So every time we discover a purely logical analysis of a concept previously thought to belong to a discipline outside logic, the acknowledged scope of logic must be expanded accordingly. The purely logical analysis of number is just one case in point, and I submit that there are many more (...) If there is anything in the analyses I will offer, then the conception of logic that emerges is very far indeed from that of Aristotle, for whom logic is primarily a tool; instead, it is more like that of Plato, for whom logic is akin to reason itself. George Bealer

Philosophical Monologues

Sunday, November 19, 2023

C. Bo, A Descriptivist Refutation of Kripke's Modal Argument and of Soames's Defence

Saturday, November 18, 2023

Kipper and Soysal, A Kripkean argument for descriptivism

A central problem of philosophy